upr000283 186

not accepted as correct. It may be that some of the additions referred to in the above list are included in the facilities ? referred to at the bottom of page 15 of the Commission's opinion which are not designated by years. An accurate comparison cannot be made, but it is certain that the total of the costs shown int he opinion for additions made in 1946 and those not assigned to any year is not equal to either $344,333.35 or $261,402.90. It is ob­vious that by disregarding the testimony in this case as to book value, the Commission has constructed from fragmentary and inaccurate information an erroneous and deficient capital base for the Railroad Company. •»^r The Commission may not validly reduce the book value *, of the facilities of the Railroad Company without evidence just­ifying its actions. The book investment is presumed to be cor­rect in the absence of an attack thereon and evidence showing them to be unreliable. The books of the Railroad Company are kept in accordance with the accounting classifications of the Interstate Commerce Commission. The following language of the United States Supreme Court in the case of West Ohio Gas Co. v. Public Utilities Commission, infra, is pertinent in this regard. In that case the Court refused to approve the disallowance by the Commission of operating expense shown in the books of the Com­pany in the following language: ”1. The company-made claim to an allowance for ’unaccounted for gas’, which is gas lost as a result of leakage, condensation, expansion or contraction. -32-